top of page

zaiath/design.by

M2/Surface vs Pattern

unimelb
fodr

Background

Subject

Year

​

Typology

Tools

Accolades

​

Studio project @ Melbourne University

ARCH10001/Foundations of Design: Representation

2023/Semester 1

​

Digital Design

Rhino 7 + Paneling Tools, Photoshop, InDesign

Marked 98/100

Module 2 contains graphic analysis, hybrid drawing formats and three-dimensional digital modelling.

In this module the basic principles of developable surfaces and fabrication processes were learnt, utilising CAD modelling program Rhino3D. Subsequently, the relationship between surface and pattern was explored, analysing how each alters visual perception. The task was to create a hybrid surface and composite, using a patterned surface and a sample from a precedent painting

Overview

Raphael, Alba Madonna, 1510. National Gallery of Art, Washington.

My painting sample features a highly distressed fabric surface that prominently diverges outward and downward from a top left point. From my sample analysis I decided to incorporate 3 visual elements: the 4 distinct creases that flow downward diagonally, the two distinct areas of highlight and undistressed fabric, and the increase in depth projected as the piece moves downward.

The Painting

Despite the complexity of trying to integrate all these aesthetic features, my justification was that they were inseparable from the visual identity of the piece and would inhibit my later formation of the composite if they were absent.

Despite the complexity of trying to integrate all these aesthetic features, my justification was that they were inseparable from the visual identity of the piece and would inhibit my later formation of the composite if they were absent.

The Landscape

My terrain was juxtaposed the painting in its relative sparsity. Dominated by a radical axis of symmetry that experiences a great elevation increase, the surface possesses only subtle additional characteristics. In response to this, I oriented my terrain’s axis to correspond with the downward diagonal axis of my fabric sample. This complimented it well, as it provided little further complexity whilst doing most of the heavy lifting in representing the increasing depth of the fabric.

The Process: Iteration

Grid Study

As the main objective of my grid study was to portray the subliminal flow and distortion of my fabric, early in my development I committed to using curve attractors to control my ptShuffleGrid command. I found that toward attractors on the bottom grid and away attractors on top gave me the most precise control over the location and degree to which I compressed or expanded my grid, as well as contributing to implying expansion in the geometry. Paired with this, I found sparse use of point attractor driven ptOffsetPoints was most effective, as they ensured that the dynamics of my grid were not overshadowed by the degree of offset.

Panel Study

As my panel study was required to represent the most detailed and complex aspects of my fabric sample, I utilised ptPanel3DCustomVariable in combination with curve attractors to provide the greatest control despite the limitations of the 10x10 grid. Whilst early on I explored the fluid and unique application of a mean meshes patterning method to great effect, I found that overall a list pattern method where I ordered my objects movement away from attractor curves in recurring sequences best allowed me to arrange my dynamic objects’ interplay with light alongside clear representation of the creases.

Hybrid Study

As both my final selection of grid and panel studies featured dynamic and complex characteristics respectively, my hybridisation process was driven by the need to simplify and consolidate my desired effects in the most effectively developable geometry possible. Correspondingly, I finally chose Hybrid 6 as I felt that despite its dynamic geometry it already resembled my painting greatly whilst still providing an adaptable and uncomplicated platform to further manipulate. In particular, the 6 point bent pyramids surrounding the geometry’s periphery had great potential to be exaggerated and expanded beyond the painting’s silhouette in the artefact process.

The Process: Artefaction

The Process: Fabrication

The Artefact

In retrospection, my composite graphic is most compelling in its juxtapositional characteristics shared between the 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional plane. Whilst my composite features portions of acute compression, dense overlap and dynamic expansion, its projection upon the painting is distinctly complementary and systematic, never drawing the observer too far away from the characteristics of the source material.


I believe this is due to its maintenance of the 3 elements identified in my initial artwork analysis. Geometries and lineworks converge along the creases of the drapery. Shapes transition from being stretched horizontally to extending vertically as they move downward, implying an increase in depth. And finally, areas initially identified as open and untensioned have been fully realised by ballooning the forms in outward expansion to imply absolute release from the creases.


This is greatly contrasted by its perception within the 3rd dimension. Featuring significant overlapping and height variation, my artefact is greatly distinct from its inspiration, functioning much more as a divergent geometry than a representational one. Indeed, in my rendering process I found that despite being placed under highly conventional lighting conditions, it remained highly spatially complex and obscured, inviting the viewer to seek additional perspectives of the geometry in order to reconnect it to the painting.


Collectively, this results in a composite that fully embraces the paradigm between the conventions of a drapery surface against the dynamic patterning of triangulated geometry. Overall, I believe my composition succeeds in being a work that reforms ‘Alba Madonna,’ rather than distort it.

Reflection

The Renderings

Raphael, Alba Madonna, 1510. National Gallery of Art, Washington.

My painting sample features a highly distressed fabric surface that prominently diverges outward and downward from a top left point. From my sample analysis I decided to incorporate 3 visual elements: the 4 distinct creases that flow downward diagonally, the two distinct areas of highlight and undistressed fabric, and the increase in depth projected as the piece moves downward.

bottom of page